INSIGHTS / THINKING
This is where I share the thinking behind the work.
Honest reflections on leadership, self-awareness, confidence, and navigating change - in work and in life.
No jargon. No noise.
Just real conversations about what actually matters.
AI and Critical Thinking: The Human Capability Gap Leaders Cannot Ignore
Much of the conversation about artificial intelligence in organisations has focused on skills.
Do employees know how to use it? Are managers adopting it? Which roles will change? What training do people need?
A new global study from the IBM Institute for Business Value suggests there may be another question leaders should be asking:
What capabilities might people lose as AI becomes part of everyday work?
The study, released on 21 September 2026, surveyed 1,500 CHROs and 8,800 full-time employees. Sixty percent of employees said they worry AI is eroding their skills, with critical thinking cited most frequently. (PR Newswire)
That alone deserves attention.
But another finding is even more interesting.
Seventy-one percent of CHROs identified the ability to supervise, validate and override AI outputs as an essential workforce skill. Yet only 29% of employees ranked judgement as important. (PR Newswire)
There is a significant human capability gap hiding inside those numbers.
Using AI is not the same as thinking well
AI can help us analyse information, draft material, identify patterns and accelerate decisions.
Those are valuable capabilities.
But the easier it becomes to generate an answer, the more important it becomes to know whether that answer should be trusted.
That requires critical thinking.
It requires context.
It requires judgement.
And sometimes it requires the confidence to say, “That doesn't look right.”
This is where the AI conversation becomes a leadership conversation.
Because organisations cannot simply train people to use AI. They also need to develop people's ability to challenge it.
Productivity without purpose is another warning sign
Culture Amp's new AI at Work Benchmark provides another useful piece of the picture.
Its analysis of approximately 112,000 employees found that 85% were being encouraged to explore AI, while only 58% said leaders had clearly explained how AI would help achieve organisational goals. Seventy-one percent said AI made them feel more productive, yet workload scores had barely shifted. (Culture Amp)
That raises an important question.
If AI creates capacity, what are we asking people to do with it?
More work?
Better work?
More thinking?
More connection?
More innovation?
Technology cannot answer that question for an organisation. Leadership has to.
Human capability needs deliberate development
For years, we have talked about human capabilities such as judgement, communication, self-awareness and critical thinking as though people simply acquire them through experience.
That assumption is becoming harder to defend.
As AI begins performing more of the thinking, analysis and early-stage work that once gave people practice, organisations may need to become far more deliberate about creating opportunities to exercise those capabilities.
This matters particularly for emerging leaders.
We cannot develop judgement without giving people decisions to make.
We cannot develop confidence without allowing people to wrestle with uncertainty.
And we cannot develop accountability if responsibility is constantly handed somewhere else.
My philosophy has always been Lead Yourself First.
In an AI-enabled workplace, I think that becomes even more important.
Use the technology.
Learn from it.
Let it make you more capable.
But don't outsource the responsibility to think, question and decide.
Because perhaps the defining human capability of the AI era won't be knowing how to get an answer.
It will be knowing what to do with one. (PR Newswire)